There are two ways to see Jean-Paul Lilienfeld’s film: with or without bias. With a bias: it’s a reactionary film filled with right-wing clichés, a public danger for democracy and affirmative action, a manipulation that condemns suburban youth -as an evidence, it shows Arabs this way and teachers that way, etc etc.
Without bias: it is at first a feature film (though it was first shown on television -on French-German channel Arte- as the financers were didn’t want to run any ‘risks’ with such a touchy subject). A film with characters –outstandingly played by Isabelle Adjiani and the young non professional actors as her pupils (much more human and moving because simply more complex than those from Laurent Cantet’s The Class). A film with an atypical mise en scène, going from tragedy to slapstick sometimes, from hysteria to smile, melodrama (yes, so what ?) to suspense, daring to embrace the path of a realistic fiction without a heavy ideological purpose. This is precisely the strength and weakness of Jean-Paul Lilienfeld’s film: he played with fire by filming a social statement, staging a reality with no consideration at all for the political correctness of the time. It would have no importance at all if the political correctness in question was on the usual wild side. But it’s definitely not that obvious here, and that’s what upsets Skirt Day opponents, the film having been strongly commented in the media and tagged as political beyond its will. From a staged reality it has become a political plot, theorized by those who already condemned a fiction which they think can only be suspicious and even worse because its many biased interpretations.
The phenomenon aroused by Skirt Day eventually highlights the torments of today’s society, torn between extremes, which are themselves somewhat desperate responses to the current immobilism of the political center, the changing and contradictory values of which exasperate those who still believe in an ideal.
There are touchy subjects (suburbs and ghettos, religion, prison etc.) that are often taken over by extreme or dominant movements, which will always create controversies everytime the references won’t be the victims’ points of view. In Skirt Day, what is not acceptable in a society where the American affirmative action has become the casual unspoken rule is that the victims are also the executioners. So the gibes will rain, the words put in mouth too, and the witch hunt can start (this very sentence could be told reactionary by the extremes intelligentsia… Whatever…)
If Jean-Paul Lilienfeld’s film has also flaws such as the attempt of the director to stuff all his thoughts and memories –he grew up in Paris surburbs- in a 88-minute film, it has the courage –some may say the naivety– to raise questions without any self-censorship and that way to be paradoxically political in its apolitical attitude because neither from left nor right, which of course is too bad for those who where expecting another film -a good partisan film (propaganda in short), tested and approved, which leaves no shades of meaning and attacks the actual authority responsible of all the things that go wrong in our society. Who could that be? Certainly not each citizen, in an un-differentiated way. One definitely needs one identified scapegoat, not several of them.
In conclusion, Skirt Day is guilty, guilty of being a fiction not “cinematographic” enough to be politically correct from its opponents’ viewpoints: a gun, a hostage-taking, the GIGN (French Swat), it’s all too realistic yet caricatured, to prevent the film from being tagged as a biased film. So the film is guilty of being precisely a feature film and not a manifesto or a clear-cut lampoon. If he wanted to please everyone, Jean-Paul Lilienfeld should have given a part to Fox and Mulder or to some sexy vampire to make the film look like cinema and not politics. Everything must be at its place: genres, classes or people can not be mixed, it is not right. But there are as many skirt days as there are days in a year. So make yourself your own opinion by watching the film… if you’re not already biased!
Françoise Duru
The DVD is released in France on September 23. More information about Skirt Day.
Skirt Day by Jean-Paul Lilienfeld (2008, France)
With Isabelle Adjani, Denis Podalydès, Yann Collette, Jackie Berroyer
Sonia Bergerac is a teacher at a school for ‘difficult’ children. The considerable problems she encounters in adapting to her new workplace are compounded by her husband’s decision to leave her and before long she is teetering on the edge of a nervous breakdown. Sonia wears a skirt to work -although the school’s head has prohibited his female staff members from doing so. Wearing a skirt certainly does not give others the right to treat her as a whore. She just wants to teach. But she’s scared, too. And that’s why she’s on antidepressants. One day, Sonia comes across a gun in one of her pupil’s school bags. Surprised, she grabs it, and, amidst the confusion accidentally fires a shot. The bullet injures her pupil’s leg. In spite of Sonia’s protestations, the commotion soon turns into a veritable hostage drama with all the usual trappings: immediate intervention on the part of the police and politicians, pa nicking parents, statements from the school’s head and teaching staff, and the arrival of the media in full force. All of which prompts a few people to drop their masks…
Watch the trailer here (French audio only):